Paul Minor’s Wife Dies Without Him

Source: Jackson Free Press in Jackson, Mississippi
April 14, 2009
By Adam Lynch

Also see: Dem At Your Own Risk

The wife of a possibly wrongfully convicted Mississippi attorney has died. Sylvia Minor, the wife of former attorney Paul Minor, died from brain cancer Monday night, former Supreme Court Justice Oliver Diaz told the Jackson Free Press.

Minor, who is serving 11 years for judicial corruption, is appealing his conviction, arguing that the U.S. Justice Department under President George Bush pushed prosecutions against Democrat politicians and Democratic fundraisers like himself in an attempt to swing elections toward Republicans. A congressional committee is investigating whether former Bush administration Chief of Staff Karl Rove influenced the Justice Department under former Attorney General Alberto Gonzales, but Rove has repeatedly refused to answer questions from the committee under oath.

Minor had asked to be released on bond April 9 pending appeal, but 5th Circuit Court Judge Priscilla Owen, who had hired Rove as a campaign manager for $250,000 to help her in her run for Texas Supreme Court in 1994, refused to grant him a bond. The panel later upheld Owen’s decision—despite the fact that she later recused herself from the panel because of conflict-of-interest issues.

Minor's father, columnist Bill Minor, called the situation "senseless," because the court may ultimately uphold the appeal—but too late for Minor to be with his dying wife. "He should have been out on bond anyway, pending appeal," Minor said today.

A three-judge panel is currently reviewing Minor’s appeal and voicing questions about the irregular jury instructions granted by Reagan appointee U.S. District Judge Henry Wingate during Minor’s 2007 trial. Wingate, after presiding over the prosecution’s failed attempt to convict Minor in a 2005 corruption trial, instructed the jury in 2007 that they did not have to find any proof of a bribery in Minor’s corruption case.

One of the panel of three judges, Will Garwood, seemed doubtful that the prosecution had outlined no particular exchange of goods in the bribery case, as did Judge Catharina Haynes.

“All right. But you agree that there has to be some kind of agreement, OK; I’m going to give you money and you're going to rule in my favor on X in some way,” Haynes said. “[W]hat is your contention of what that agreement was? Because neither of these two cases (used to convict the defendants) that we have been presented were pending in front of those judges at that time as I understand it.”

The panel will decide on the appeal at an unspecified date.

Minor had recently asked U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder to weigh in on his release request, although Holder had not responded as of her death, according to Minor's father.

“Paul tried everything he could to be with Sylvia in her last days,” said Diaz, a Democratic-leaning judge unsuccessfully prosecuted by U.S Attorney Dunn Lampton during the Minor trial, although Diaz never presided over any of Minor’s disputed cases. “We just wish their family well, and we’re sorry he couldn’t be with her.”

The panel told Minor last month that he could still petition the Federal Bureau of Prisons for a temporary release, although the bureau had allowed little humanity in Minor’s last petition. His last temporary release through the bureau’s generosity got him three hours with his wife in February.

Minor’s lawyer Hiram Eastland told the Jackson Free Press that Sylvia Minor drifted in and out of consciousness during that visit and said it was doubtful that she even remembered seeing her husband’s face. Minor's father said that, as of this morning, Paul Minor does not know whether he will be able to attend the funeral.

© Jackson Free Press, Inc.